Science

Developing an Analog Understanding of the Digital World

Nino Mindiashvili
Paula Bleckmann

Just a few months ago, the newly appointed Minister of Education, Karin Prien, announced that she would place «smartphone bans» in schools high on her political agenda. Since the start of the school year following the summer break, several state-specific regulations on this matter have already gone into effect.  In addition, the Leopoldina has taken a clear stance in the debate over social media bans for children under 16: Children under 13 should not use social media. For 13- to 17-year-olds, use should only be permitted with age-appropriate restrictions and protective measures. In Australia, such a restriction has been in effect since last year.

Even as we welcome the fact that policymakers are finally taking digital risks for children seriously, dissenting voices are being heard: The bans would be ineffective—and even harmful—because children need to learn how to use devices and apps responsibly. These dissenting voices are just what the major media conglomerates want. They fuel the narrative of an irresolvable dilemma: protection from risks on the one hand, and the development of media literacy and digital education on the other.

Protection and empowerment in practice

Precisely to undermine such dilemma-based narratives, it’s worth taking a look at how media education is implemented in Waldorf schools. Here, the two can go hand in hand. It is possible to protect children while also empowering them. Author Nino Mindiashvili initially developed the block in a condensed form in 2020 and has continued to expand upon it since then. It teaches skills that will later be important for using digital devices—and social media in particular—without the use of computers or smartphones in the classroom. The first lesson plans for this were created by educator Brigitte Pemberger.

As part of Mindiashvili’s doctoral dissertation at Alanus University, the experiences of teachers, students, and parents were documented and analyzed. The dissertation was supervised by co-author Paula Bleckmann and funded by the Graduate College for Waldorf Education.

Secret writing in the classroom

As a small note makes its way down the rows, the classroom falls completely silent. The note is actually meant to reach a student sitting in the very back. But everyone reads it before it reaches its intended recipient. «Who read the note even though it was meant for someone else?» the teacher asks. Almost all hands shoot up, accompanied by laughter. On the second round, the message looks different: cryptic symbols, scrambled letters—no one understands it right away. «Who read the message?»—this time, the room remains silent. In moments like these, the topic becomes more than just academic material: the children experience firsthand what encryption means.

This game marks the culmination of a media block titled From Hieroglyphs to ASCII Code. It is designed for 5th and 6th graders, traces the history of communication through the evolution of media, and simultaneously teaches the fundamentals of computer science education.

Cryptography: From the scytale to Caesar

The history of cryptography goes back a long way. In Sparta, messengers would wrap strips of leather around a rod and write messages that could only be read again using a rod of the same diameter: the scytale. Next, the students explore the Caesar cipher. Julius Caesar is said to have protected his military correspondence by shifting letters three places in the alphabet. For advanced learners, the shift can be varied from one to 25 positions. «Plain text letters» are assigned to «ciphertext letters.» Thus, a D becomes a G, an A becomes a D, and the word DAS becomes gdv.

Each student makes their own Caesar wheel. Afterward, the groups decode prepared messages—or encrypt their own messages for others to crack. This is precisely where the power of such educational experiments lies: in the sense of wonder, the struggle, and the shared process of figuring things out. The message isn’t immediately apparent—and that’s precisely where the joy lies. When a jumble of letters turns into a clear word, a spark is ignited.

From wooden sticks to the digital age

The exciting conclusion to the block is a cryptographic scavenger hunt. A main message is wrapped around a skytale rod and must be decoded. Additional clues are hidden between the stations. At the end, the solution word is written on the board. The scytale rod hadn’t been introduced before, so this method is new. One student reports: «At first, I didn’t get the trick with the rod at all—but once you understand it, it gets easier.»

The treasure hunt doesn’t end in antiquity. At the very least, when it comes to the issue of privacy, the topic bridges the gap to the present day. What once protected messages from rulers now secures emails, online banking, and digital elections. The discussion comes alive: Who is allowed to read my messages? What rights do I have to my information? Why does a letter have to be sealed? The comparison between a sealed envelope and an encrypted message online sheds light on connections that children would otherwise hardly notice.

From a methodological perspective, the scavenger hunt offers variety. It promotes teamwork, problem-solving, concentration, and creativity. It combines hands-on skills, language skills, mathematical thinking, and social experience: building the stick, encoding texts, looking for patterns, and working together as a team.

Skepticism gives way to enthusiasm

At first, teachers viewed the block with skepticism. Teaching computer science in middle school was not common practice. They wondered whether the content was age-appropriate and feasible. Once the block had been completed and it became clear that the topics sparked interest, their reservations faded. A classroom observation helped encourage colleagues to recommend the block to one another. Skepticism turned into enthusiasm. One teacher reported: «We played this game—a kind of scavenger hunt. The code was relatively difficult, but the kids immediately made the connection to the letters and realized right away: ‹Ah, that’s shifted by so many positions.› I thought that was exciting!»

Stimulate curiosity rather than creating problems

Finally, on a more fundamental level: Discussing data protection and privacy with students is a balancing act between being too early and too late, too technical and too vague. Studies show that too many scare tactics—such as the shocking images once used in smoking prevention campaigns—do not achieve lasting protective effects. Instead, it tends to spark curiosity about the forbidden or feelings of helplessness in the face of the complexity. Researchers refer to this as problem fatigue: an information overload about the consequences of disclosing personal data leads to resignation along the lines of, «I know all that already, but there’s nothing I can do about it anyway—everyone does it that way these days.» This doesn’t just affect children.

As an alternative, we rely on an approach that appeals to curiosity and age-appropriate interests and incorporates these topics in a playful way through action-oriented instruction. What is privacy? What is data protection? How do I create a particularly secure password? The research study mentioned above has yielded very promising initial results. It was recently published online: URN: urn:nbn:de:0111-pedocs-341151.

What really matters

One thing is certain, however: the «high-tech» solutions long favored in education policy do not work automatically. The idea that students’ computer and information literacy could be improved primarily through more and more expensive digital devices in schools—a push driven by the Digital Pact with its five billion euros—has not proven true. It wasn’t just the Waldorf education movement that was skeptical; others expressed doubts as well. Among them is Thorsten Brinda, president of the German Informatics Society. He has repeatedly emphasized that what matters is fostering analytical thinking skills and mathematical understanding, not simply hauling in devices. «Digital education doesn’t arrive on a moving truck,» he said.

Info Box:

You can find more lesson examples that make cryptography fun in the book Analog vor Digital. The entire book is available for free at www.analog-digidaktik.de.

Comments

There are no comments yet

Add comment

0 / 2000

Thank you for your comment. It will be published after review by the administrators.